Why CEC’s recommendation with regard to Navin Chawla must be accepted by Government
The current controversy surrounding Election Commissioner Shri Navin Chawla reminds me of a conversation I had had with Benazir Bhutto when she visited Delhi during the NDA regime. She had lunch with me that day and she shared with me a delicious dish of Sindhi curry, which my wife Kamala prepares excellently.
In the post lunch chat we had that day, I posed a question to Benazir: “How is it” I asked her, “that though both India’s as well as Pakistan’s political leadership had imbibed a similar political culture under British rule, India had managed its democracy with remarkable success but in Pakistan democracy had been a total failure.” Benazir’s reply was succinct: “I attribute your country’s success to two factors: firstly, your Army is apolitical; and secondly, your Election Commission is constitutionally independent of the Executive.”
Benazir had rightly identified the two guarantees for Indian democracy. For the first of these ― the Indian Army never nurturing political ambitions of any kind ― the credit goes entirely to our armed forces and those who have led it since independence, while credit for the Election Commission’s independence must be given to the Constituent Assembly.
There were, however, eminent participants in the Constituent Assembly debate on Art. 324, who wanted the Election Commission to be invested with even greater independence than given to it. These members did not approve of the fact that the Election Commission was to be appointed by the Central Government, and that the safeguards provided to the Commission were limited to its removal. Speaking on the occasion, Pandit Hriday Nath Kunzru said:
“ We are anxious, Sir, that the preparation of the election rolls and the conduct of elections should be entrusted to people who are free from political bias and whose impartiality can be relied upon in all circumstances. But, by leaving a great deal of power in the hands of the President we have given room for the exercise of political influence in the appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner and the other officers by the Central government. The Chief Election Commissioner will have to be appointed on the advice of the Prime Minister, and if the Prime Minister suggests the appointment of a party man, the President will have no option but to accept the Prime Minister’s nominee, however unsuitable he may be on public ground”.
In 2006, the then Chief Election Commissioner Shri B.B. Tandon, in a well-argued letter addressed to Rashtrapati Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, had pleaded with Government that just as in the case of the Central Vigilance Commission and the National Human Rights Commission, the appointments are made not by the Executive but by Committees in which the Speaker of the Lok Sabha and Leaders of Opposition in Parliament are also included, in case of the Election Commission also, a similar Committee should be authorized to do so. Shri Tandon concludes his letter to Dr. Kalam with the observation:
“This approach would not only be in keeping with the spirit and sentiment flowing from the debates in the Constituent Assembly but also further strengthen the faith of the people of our great democracy in the continued impartiality, neutrality and credibility of the Election Commission.”
In the context of the current controversy about Shri Navin Chawla, it would be educative to compare Art.124 dealing with the Supreme Court, with Art.324 laying down provisions relating to the Election Commission. Art.124 provides that neither the Chief Justice of India nor any other judge of the Supreme Court can be removed from his office except by a process of impeachment laid down by Parliament. In case of the Election Commission, however, this kind of protection is provided only to the Chief Election Commissioner, and not to the Election Commissioners. In case of the other Election Commissioners the Constitution says that they “shall not be removed from office except on the recommendation of the Chief Election Commissioner.”
On behalf of the BJP, Party General Secretary, Shri Arun Jaitley has rightly argued that the word ‘recommendation’ used in the second proviso of Article 324(3) must be construed as a binding recommendation. Jaitley has drawn attention to Article 217 of the Constitution relating to appointment of High Court Judges where the appointment is to be “after consultation with the Chief Justice”, the Chief Justice’s views has always been regarded binding.
The Party therefore, feels that the Chief Election Commissioner’s recommendation with regard to Shri Navin Chawla must be forthwith accepted by Government.
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!
February 1st, 2009 at 7:07 pm
Dear Advaniji,
This issue of ‘NAVIN CHAWLA’ is of utmost significance to “INDIAN DEMOCRACY”,The NON CONGRESS parties were strengthened only after Mr.T N Seshan,played his constitutional role at his best and actaull showed the ‘ROLE AND POWER’ of the CEC.While the ex CEC Mr.GILL who was famous for his fued with T N SESHAN, is a MINISTER in the present UPA government,it shows what CONGRESS is upto with CHAWLA,BJP should fight tooth and nail to oust CHAWLA,the succession of CHAWLA as CEC would be the end of a TRANSPARENT and IMPARTIAL CEC.
Regards
Puneeth kumar
February 1st, 2009 at 7:35 pm
I agree that Chawla should go. He should never have been appointed as an EC in the first place.
An unrelated point i want to make here. I have been completely disillusioned with the BJP. I had always been a BJP supported and voter. I voted for the BJP (R Ashok) in the last Karnataka assembly elections. Now, I am not sure I would vote for the BJP in the coming lok sabha elections. Why? Mangalore. I don’t want to get into the debate about so-called “Pub culture”. What dismays me most that the state has ceded space to goondas. If the BJP-led government can enforce law and order in the face of a few goondas and extortionists, what hope can we have that it will protect us from terrorists? I won’t by the BJP’s excuse that the incident was a conspiracy by opposition parties. Then please expose the conspiracy and ensure that the stringent punishment is meted to the so-called conspirators. Also, the BJP led goverment in Karnataka has done absolutely nothing on the infrastructure front.
February 1st, 2009 at 7:37 pm
[...] L.K. Advani writing in his blog had this to say in reaction to the Chief Election Commissioner’s suo moto recommendation on the removal of controversial election commissioner Navin Chawla. The current controversy [...]
February 1st, 2009 at 7:55 pm
We are cetainly suprised the way government is being casual in issues like terrorism and now plugging in their mole in one of the prestigious and pillars of democracy institute.
February 1st, 2009 at 8:38 pm
what ever the bjp says or shows to the govt about the illegality of the naveen chawala,it is concluding that the cong wouldnot heed to the law of the land as it is afraid of losing the next elections and want that the next cec would be naveen chawla who would be utilised to rig the elections.why shout so.why not all the bjp mps resign en mass immediately and force the govt to declare the election immediately.the parliament should be halted. no legislative busines should be allowed to be conducted including the budget proposal by the nda mps.when a govt goes wrong or try to go wrong it is the duty of the oppn parties to set it right by virtue of strong protests in all the spheres including judiciary.why not the bjp take the issue to supreme court for clearing the clouds and fogs of constitutional ambiguity.
February 1st, 2009 at 10:39 pm
Advani Ji,
Namaskar,
My this comment is not pertaining to this post, my apologies.
I just wanted to ask you the relevance of giving you life time achievement award by NDTV.
Was it intended to convey something?
May I request you to kindly educate us on this media game.
February 1st, 2009 at 11:00 pm
Right from the time Mr Chawla was appointed as the EC, even Congress supporters were suprised since the proximity of Mr Chawla to the Congress party for the past 30 years is very well know. After watching the interesting debate between Mr Jaitley and Mr Singhvi on NDTV, I would like to make a suggestion: Would it be possible for Mr Jaitley/BJP to writed a detailed sequence of events from the appointment of Mr Chawla in May 2005 till date, and that be published in various National and Regional newspapers. I think citizens should be aware of the wrong-doings the Congress has been and is always upto. I am really worried about what will happen once the CEC retires in April 2009, when the Lok Sabha elections will be in full swing……
February 1st, 2009 at 11:57 pm
truly said sir,
Chavla sahab is having long relation with congress.He was the person who brought the polling after emergency.Her wife always reciee large amount of funds and charity from lots of congress ministers.
Sir,
in a similar case can you also pay attention on “RTI act 2005 clauses 8(1)(e) and 8(1)(j) “. This prevails us to get personal information of ministers.
How can we claim a minister corrupt unless we know his/her economy.
http://www.hindu.com/thehindu/holnus/000200902011740.htm
Please see this case. PMO refused to make a list of ministers and their total property.
Regards,
Mayank SHukla
February 2nd, 2009 at 1:26 am
Dear Advani ji,
You are absolutely correct. The EC must be a neutral body, not filled by partisans.
Navin Chawla is a Nautanki Chawla. He must be sacked !!!
February 2nd, 2009 at 1:36 am
Friends,
If I may add one more thing:
Shri. Navin Chawla has been a Congress Partisan since the days of the 1977 Emergency, and his recent antics have proved that he has not lost his touch.
Keeping a Congress Partisan in line to be the next Chief Election Commissioner (who will conduct the 2009 Parliamentary Elections this April-May) is as prudent as appointing a Fox to guard the Chicken Coop (Poultry Farm).
I sincerely hope the Indian Government and the Indian President, Smt.Pratibha Patil behaves fairly in maintaining the neutrality of the Election Commission and accepting the recommendation of the current CEC to dismiss Chawla.
History will judge the fairness and honesty of the Indian Government and the Office of the Indian President. So, let the Powers-That-Be keep this in mind at this juncture….. Do they want to remembered throughout history as noble Harishchandras or as evil Shakunis?
February 2nd, 2009 at 2:29 am
Indeed, the neutrality of Election Commission now can only be restored if Navin Chawla is shown the door. But, given the track record of this government and ingeneral Congress Party, I don’t have any hope.
Congress didn’t ’send’ Navin Chawla to EC to be removed. He will have to ‘deliver’ to Congress.. 2009 elections will be his term to ‘return’ the favor. Prime Minister - as you have already said that is Weakest ever in our history - will not be in any mood or even authority to act correctly on it! Ma’am will call the shots..!!! And she knows whats the obstacles in her sons way to be come PM!!! She will make sure that Chawla remain.
February 2nd, 2009 at 4:34 am
It is great to see you Sir,connecting with the youth of India through this blog.I’d like to compliment you on this endeavor,and extend my best wishes to you.This will be my first vote for the Lok Sabha elections,and having voted once in the recent assembly elections in MP,I am all geared up now to vote for my favourite party again
Your explanation on why Shri Nawin Chawla should be removed was intriguing,however it looks like the government is in no mood to oblige.I really hope that they change their stand and uphold the dignity of our Constitution
PS - Just a small point Sir.Your welcome message on the site,is it written by your staff? Somehow,it does not have the spontaneity that we are used to in your speeches.Also,the message of ‘Change’ sounds a little cliched and after being overused by Obama, I don’t think it appeals so much to bloggers, who are saturated with Obama and his rhetoric
My apologies if I have gone overboard with the criticism.
February 2nd, 2009 at 9:44 am
Dear Mr Advani,
i completely agree with you on the suggested appointment structure of EC members. There cannot be a better choice which is in consultation with Leader of Opposition and speaker, this way the EC members become truly impartial.
For that matter even at present crisis Manamohan Singh has an easy option of following footsteps of Atal Bihari Bajpeyee. All he needs to do is to call an all party meet, present the facts before everyone and then decide on consensus.
I already know that this is a wishful thinking and the utopia of having congress acting free of its inherent desires to establish unsaid monarchy is far fetched, but then this is all democracy is all about - freedom to dream
February 2nd, 2009 at 10:46 am
what is ailing this country,we don’t understand.self righteousness by the congress is highly ambiguous.why it so.it is superiority complex and mentality of oneupmanship and dictatorial tendency who never believe in democratic institutions.being a party with a small MP seats in lokasabha and by virtue of succumbing to pressures of regional parties and held ransom by them.now the slave mentality of other opposition parties seems to have dampened indian democracy.
February 2nd, 2009 at 11:51 am
EC Chawla sat on the letter of CEC for six months and did not reply. When CEC got the reply and did not find it suitable, he sent his letter to the President. This aspect is being ignored by a section of press and motive is being discovered behind CEC’s letter. This is wrong.
Election Commission is a great institution and Shri Advani’s recommendations makes sense in the light of last CEC’s letter to Pres Kalam. Partisan politics should be avoided and an effective way out should be found to ensure Election Commission continue to work independently.
February 2nd, 2009 at 1:04 pm
About Why CEC recommendation is binding :-
It is necessary to understand the relevance of article 217 in current context and why recommendation is adjudged as binding. Judiciary is supposed to be independent of Executive and hence, ignoring the recommendation of Chief justice is tantamount to subversion of judiciary by executive.
In case of Election commission, Election commission is supposed to be independent of Executive. Hence, ignoring the recommendation of CEC tantamount to subversion of Election Commission.
February 2nd, 2009 at 1:38 pm
Respected Adwani ji,
you are absolutely correct in your view. Naveen Chawla must be dismissed immediately. Since his appointment in election commission he is working as a devoted worker of Congress party. If he became chief Election commissioner as expected this will be great misfortune for our nation. i request to you kindly oppose highly in this case. we don’t want congress once again.
with best wishes
vinay
February 2nd, 2009 at 9:03 pm
[...] the Navin Chawla case will head to the courts and arguments will be made on the Constitutional merits of the CEC’s powers (Manjoj Mitta in the TOI) For, all that Article 324(5) of the [...]
February 3rd, 2009 at 1:38 am
By B S Raghavan - on Rediff. Please publish this article as much as you can:
http://in.rediff.com/news/2009/feb/02bsraghavan-its-unfair-to-impute-motives-to-cec.htm (Please read full article )
February 3rd, 2009 at 3:25 am
[...] Sept 12th to the CEC, the CEC was not satisfied with that reply and hence asked for a reply on the merits of the petition from Navin Chawla which never come until the December 10th reiteration of the earlier [...]
February 3rd, 2009 at 4:05 am
Dear Advaniji,
Whatever your party is doing regarding the CEC issue is not even near enough. The country is again gone to dogs (80s have returned back in full form) and the tactics to fight evil have to be different from what your partymen are doing. A DAY IS NOT FAR AWAY WHEN YOU CANNOT UNDERSTAND WHEN A VERY GOOD MEMBER OF YOUR PARTY IN A VERY COMFORTABLE SEAT LOST THE ELECTION.
I hate to say this but your party is heading for a disaster inspite of your best efforts if issues like this are seriously dealt with. We do not see the energitic response that is required.
Regards,
February 3rd, 2009 at 6:29 am
Honorable AdvaniJI,
Who cares the system, BJP has thinkers and Congress has tinkers. Always unto selfish motive. Lobbiest always wins and not Loyalist to the book of rights v/s wrongs. We want to see you there at center witness the sea of change. This navin chawal must leave the CEC for Clean & apolitical chair if he has best heart for India.
February 3rd, 2009 at 12:11 pm
Dear Respected and lovable Advani ji ,
Thank you very much for joining the internet blogging. I am happy the way you are updating yourself with new technology . I need your opinion on following subjects.
What is your opinion on Two party system in Indian democracy. Do you think our democratic system will work in a better way if we have two parties only. Big parties forms alliance after election only. These alliances are not based of fundamental principles or ideology. This is based on purely mathematical addition to touch magic figure. Take example of Congress was with BSP for 4 yrs after they are with SP .
What are your planning to inject new blood in Indian politics. Take example of United States head of US is only 46 yo, whereas our main political leaders are more than 60yrs. This year how much percentage of lok sabha tickets has been allocated to young people.
Loving you
Your grandson
Sarvesh Pal
February 3rd, 2009 at 12:27 pm
Dear Sir,
All the comments we have been reading both from Congress perspective (N Ram in the Hindu), BJP perspective and neutral are based on technical flaws of the constitution after permanent ECs were appointed in 2004. What is the ethical or moral ground for defending such a person? Shouldn’t this be taken between party leaders to arrive at a consensus? In every Indian’s view, it is good if such people are not holding high posts.
Regards,
JV
February 3rd, 2009 at 7:02 pm
dear Mr. L.K.Advaniji
Indias law minister acting as a spokesperson for an individual Mr. Chawla indicates that something is cooking between Mr. chawla and the congress led UPA government. Mr.chawla should be barred from EC for his entire life and lawsuit must be filed against him.
February 3rd, 2009 at 9:12 pm
Respected Advaniji,
Sadar Pranam. You have been a life long champion for fair electoral processes in India throughout your political career. Thanks to your priceless documentation of facts in your work ‘My Country, My Life’, young Indians like me now have an opportunity to recognise the glowing facts even though they are buried under decades of state-sponsored ‘propaganda’.
As for Navin Chawla, his controversial role as secretary to the Lt. Governor of Delhi was noted by the Shah Commission which went into Emergency Excesses. As Mr. V Sundaram (a retired IAS officer) honestly highlights in his article at News Today: “As one who occupied a vantage position during that period, he was charged with arbitrary exercise of authority. Justice Shah had commented on Navin Chawla in his report: ‘Navin Chawla became the Lieutenant Governor of Delhi and Kishan Chand the Lieutenant Governor became Navin Chawla’s lieutenant’. (contd.)
February 3rd, 2009 at 9:14 pm
Thus this Chawla, the distinguished Daftri (perhaps ‘Chaprasi’) of the Nehru dynasty and Sanjay Gandhi’s Man Friday was illegitimately rewarded by the government of India for his life-long loyalty not to the nation but to a family. Thus the ghosts of the Emergency were finally exorcised by the elevation of Navin Chawla to the post of Election Commissioner.” Echoing similar concerns, in his farewell remarks, the outgoing Chief Election Commissioner Krishnamurthy had also rightly noted that he feared the politicisation of the commission.
V. Sundaram further draws our attention in his article referring to Navin Chawla on very pertinent questions: “Using his official influence in the Indian Administrative Service and with the full blessings of his Mother Superior (the same Madame who controls our current PM), he has collected large sums of money for a non-governmental agency being run by his wife Rupika Chawla under the contrived umbrella of ‘Social Work and Social Service’. (contd.)
February 3rd, 2009 at 9:16 pm
Contd. -
Ambika Soni seems to have contributed Rs 15 lakh, Karan Singh Rs 10 lakh, A R Kidwai Rs 45 lakh and God only knows how much money other Congressmen have contributed to this great humanitarian effort without parallel in human history! Are they all preparing themselves for 2009 elections? Are they all doing strategic perspective planning?”
It would be an extremely uphill task for a non-corrupt government not only to help purge the political biases from the nation’s highest offices but also the omnipresent media. All pervasive channels like NDTV and IBN-CNN have consistently been Congress-controlled mediums of political campaign. These channels have raged months of propaganda-wars against opposition leaders like Narendra Modi and, despite his historic victory, are still on constant lookout for excuses to vandalize his credibility. (contd.)
February 3rd, 2009 at 9:24 pm
Contd. -
One recent example is the fake uproar designed and aired by these channels on some business leaders’ comments on Modi’s leadership skills. All one needs to do is to visit the ‘Jitega Gujarat’ website to watch the actual video footage of these ‘alleged’ comments by the industrialists. At no point in their comments, businessmen have wished him to be the next ‘Prime Minister’ of the country – a phrase completely fabricated by the news channels and repeatedly beamed to brainwash the common man.
(Contd.)
February 3rd, 2009 at 9:24 pm
Contd. -
This problem has it’s roots in decades of intentional grooming of an elitist and Anglicized class of Indians who are trained to be devoid of honour and self-dignity. Part of their syllabus has been to demonise Hinduism as a book of superstitions. They are blind to the glaring fact that the tolerant principles of true Hinduism itself have been the sole integrator of a real India for ages. No wonder, they look up to West for certification of what is good / right and look down upon on anything Hindu or Indian as malicious. Even some honest men of the West have admitted the manufacture of such zombies as shown in the recent article ‘Pale Fires Don’t Scorch’ by Francois Gautier at Outlook magazine Feb 09 edition.
http://www.outlookindia.com/full.asp?fodname=20090209&fname=Cover+Story&sid=6
February 3rd, 2009 at 11:06 pm
Dear Advaniji,
I would like to see constructive politics especially from a person like you, who has great potential to drive our nation. I still feel that we are spending a lot of time in unnecessary arguments and counter statement which lead us no where. My apolozies if I hurt any one with this statement. I dont say that we have put forth the loop poles in system, but we have to limit it to very small extent. I would like here from you, my favourite leader, what will be your policy both economic, defence and external affairs for the next 5 years. How are we going to face the global economic cricis. What is your stand on Indian agriculture sector, will there again be loan waveoff or some really helping hand. Please please comment on this.
Krishna
February 4th, 2009 at 2:17 am
Pranam sir,
I don’t know the constitution of india, how this matter is discribe in our constitution very nicely or not.And we know that every person can not be T N Sheson who perform his duty by respondily.So ,like this condition if genrate in future then who will be responsible for this………..we or our constitution…….
So, there should be a very precisly constitution about this matter by which country can get their perfect leader…………….thank you.
February 4th, 2009 at 2:48 am
Dear Advaniji,
I have an unbiased and non-political view about EC Navin Chawla. He should be removed at first place. Justice should not only be done but also to be seen. If the Chief EC has no faith on him how can a general voter will have it?
Navin Chawla has shown his bias in previous elections but that was ignored by the Government. Now it is high time to remove him because Chief EC himself has recommended for him.
Regards,
Jyoti Kothari
http://vardhamangems.webs.com
February 4th, 2009 at 3:01 am
Respected Mr. Advaniji
I am really thankful for your way to connecting with youth.
I also strongly support you on this issue.
On this particular episode of Mr. Chawla as a citizen i want put some questions.
Why only the BJP is raising issue? means why not NDA or other opposition parties? why there is no consensus between oposition parties also?
Because it shows that BJP is only party in this battle.
Why BJP is not going once again to the supreme court for the issue?
Why BJP or rather NDA can not come from resigning parlament and pose the election eariler as suggested in one of your comment?
your answers will not for me but for the people of this nation.
Thank you
February 4th, 2009 at 4:50 am
The absence of equality among the EC’s is a serious lacuna and must be corrected. It is quite logical to presume that the CEC is the first among equals. But this has not been accorded constitutional sanction since in the era of coalitions it is virtually impossible to obtain the two-third majority that this will require. Since all these processes are time-consuming, in order to meet the exigencies of the current situation, the president must extend the tenure of the current by a suitable time period till the next round of Lok Sabha Elections are completed.
February 4th, 2009 at 4:54 am
The letters ‘CEC’ were inadvertently left out in my above comments (in the penultimate line).
February 4th, 2009 at 7:45 am
Congress has been destroying institutions since 2004. Primary worry being their comparable performance with BJP led regime. BJPs handling of the economy saw a boom in housing sector, manufacturing and what not. Quota system was abolished by BJP. A gas connection used to cost Rs 4000 before BJP regime and when BJP cam to power it was distributed for Rs 500. Telephone connection applied in 1989 was released in 1998. A common man could dream of a home thanks to low intrest rates in BJP regime. BJP handed over a robust India with robust economy to UPA and what is there now. empty coffers. Congress always used blackmarketting tool to fill the coffers of its partymen. Security of Nation is at its low with no clue as to what this Govt has to do. The only way for it to stick to power is the short cut to destroy the institution called EC
February 4th, 2009 at 8:40 am
Dear Mr Advani,
I read about the CM’s meet to discuss the Lok Sabha polls. Why weren’t the BJP leaders from the non- BJP states invited as well. This election is very crucial and I hope the BJP are working on key issues to be raised. Already there is going to be a huge unemployment issue that can be raised in addition to the rate of growth witnessed in the past years.
I really think that focusing only on the BJP ruled states will not be very helpful. By correcting the mistakes made in Rajasthan and Delhi, I am sure the BJP can win more seats in these States/ UTs as well. We really want the NDA in power so that development continues as it was during Atalji’s time. I take this opportunity to wish Atalji a speedy recovery!!
February 4th, 2009 at 8:41 am
In addition I would like to request the BJP to stay away from organisations like the Ram Sena who will do nothing but malign the BJP. The Congress is doing all possible to woo the youth and there shouldn’t be a reverse action from the BJP. The youth are a force to recon with in the coming election and moral policing not only in urban but rural areas will totally backfire. We are living in a Democracy and we have the right to live the way we want to, if our families’ do not have an issue on how “free” we as the youth are, why should any organisation or party be involved. Please make sure that in your BJP ruled states no untoward incidents take place on Valentines Day because this will only alienate the youth further. We have witnessed youth anger in both BJP and non- BJP ruled States in the past weeks over this very issue.
February 4th, 2009 at 11:16 am
Dear Advaniji,
your candid and stark views on latest CEC row is commendable and very rationale in all count.However,entire issue needs to be addressed in much more comprehensive way rather than leaving it to mere a political.As everbody knows that in Aprlil,Mr.Gopalaswami would retire and his deputy,Mr.Navin chawla will take over CEC chair.Now ,when things have become fully transparent that Mr. Naving chawala is acting at the behest of Inida’a premier political party and it would be more dangerous to allow such a person to lead such a highest constitutional authority of India.The open comment by Law minister leaves shows the partisanship and malafide intention of the incumbent goverment for the forthcoming LS pools.I would request you,sir, that massive pressure should be launched to prevent Mr. Chawla to occupy highest constitutional authority to satiate one political party’s vested interest.
February 4th, 2009 at 11:46 am
Dear Advaniji,
We should be proud of the independence our defense forces and election commission, which maintains the true spirit of democracy. But as citizens( including you and me) , do we enjoy a social security ? Does our government and the administrative system guarantee us the same? As tax payers are we in the same position of our counterparts in UK, US ,Canada Australia etc.
Regards
Freddy
http://www.sailorsdiary.com
February 4th, 2009 at 6:32 pm
Respected Sir,
Definitely you are the only politician in India, after Sh Vajpayee, who has a vision for India and has got decades of the experience of Indian conditions at your back. Who else is best suited to lead this country except you. These days congress is championing the youth card. If one looks at Congress youth brigade,it comprises of Sonia’s son, scindia’s son, pilot’s son, Tiwari’s son, jindal’s son., Dutt’s daughter…..The list will start and end at the congressman’s son or daughter, Except for these inheritors there is no room for a common youth in the congress. Looking at UPA allies youth, these are mulayam’s son, karuna’s son, farooq’s son, muftis daughter…… So please dont worry youth of this country is behind you.
February 4th, 2009 at 7:55 pm
Advaniji,
The state of Indian politics scares me. With every passing day one gets to believe that politicians can tamper with anything and everything if they are power. Its sad our politicians are ready to do anything just to hold on to their positions. I pity this country!
February 5th, 2009 at 12:09 am
Respected Advani ji,
As you correctly pointed out, the Constitution does allow the CEC to remove anyone from the Election Panel. It is an open and shut case. If the government believes that Gopalaswami has acted in bad faith, or vindictively towards Chawla, the former should be duly accused in a civil court. In the meanwhile, there is no excuse for suspending the executive powers of the Chief Election Commissioner. In fact, the Law Ministry has almost borne out the accusation made by Mr. Gopalaswami by publicly announcing, ahead of time, that Chawla would be installed as next Chief Election Commissioner.
Regards,
Abhishek
http://theindianoracle.blogspot.com/
February 5th, 2009 at 12:22 am
Advaniji,
I am really happy that you ventured into the online world to spread your message.
I hope to read some interesting and relevant posts on this blog.
Also, I have written you an email on your nic email address. I have not received any acknowledgement of the email but I hope it would somehow find it’s way to you.
Sincerely,
Saurabh Dwivedi
February 5th, 2009 at 12:29 am
Respected Sir,
I have been reading about this and what i conclude is that mr. naveen chawla has not held the dignity of the post.however i should bring to your notice or rather ask about the partisanship on account of the print media who are alleging that Mr. N. Gopalaswamy has used his discretion in a wrong way..i sincerly doubt about the authenticity of print media..whether the UPA is controlling it also…UPA wants his person to be the next chief election commissioner of india as they did in case of our President Mrs. Pratibha Patil…I can only beseech you to take a firm stand on preventing the sanctity of these revered posts whatever steps you have to take..please “LET THE TRUTH PREVAIL”.
Regards
Shashwat Pandey
February 5th, 2009 at 4:37 am
Respected Advaniji,
In 1990 rath yatra, I heard your speech for the first time, I`was 15 years then. I have been reading and listening to your inspiring speeches and thoughts regularly. Thank you for being such a brave and intelligent leader. I wish you all the best. Vande mataram.
February 5th, 2009 at 9:47 am
Dear Advaniji,
Congress culture will not change !! Old habits are hard to die. They will use every possible tool to murder the spirit of democracy. But, today, India is much more educated and better connected. We may not realize it , but the electonic media bashes the BJP for the silliest of reasons, and what do we do? — Like Hindus have done over the last 1000 years, sit quite and dont react. React we must !! It’s high time the BJP becomes more proactive in media management, because they influence millions of viewers. Chawla must go!!
February 5th, 2009 at 12:58 pm
Dear Advani ji,
Everybody is busy critising menace of corruption , but why do we fail to understand that curbing this evil will require unprecedented measures which may not be clearly writen in the constitution but it is well hidden in the core of the constitution . IN THIS CASE CONSTITUTION IS VERY CLEAR THAT CEC CAN SACK AN EC IF CEC DEEMS THAT THE GIVEN EC IS UNFIT FOR SUCH A HIGH AND RESPONSIBLE OFFICE……
POLITICAL helm of UPA at present is very eager to reduce all constitutional watchdogs like EC, NHRC,GOVERNOR’s office , NWC, CIC, CAG etc .It is also making audacious attempts to subdue JUDICIARY ( which is comparatively clean and has inbuilt mechanism to check the loopholes ) in name of curbing corruption amongst judges. Had CONGRESS really been serious about cleaning the judiciary , it would have not shown its awkward and reluctant stand when SC asked parliament to impeach JUSTICE RAMASWAMY after finding charges against him to be true .
PAST CONGRESS GOVTS INCLUDING THE PRESENT ONE have already succeeded in taming and subsequently exploiting autonomous bodies like CBI (which is also a tool for teaching political opponents a good lesson ) and IB like agencies busy taping phones of opposition leaders . Dictating terms were well evident in the way by which defence minister A K ANTONY handled the 3 SERVICE CHEIFS who were unwilling to accept the ill framed PAY REVISIONS for armed forces . Ironically the series of events after Mumbai attacks forced the government to dissolve the fury amongst armed forces . What could be more shameful that we need high magnitude Mumbai type attacks to give the foremost sacrificer their due privileges ( more precisly their rights ) .
Supreme court has shown an unprecedented activism in recent years to safeguard the constitution on the issues in which it is not very clear (because our forefathers never expected that politics will see drastic changes forgetting GANDHIAN and NEHRUVIAN legacy ) . So shall we rate this non-bookish and unconventional activism a ” A CONSTITUTIONAL OVERREACH ” . In both cases of Jharkhand confidence motion and Bihar assembly dissolution NDA was the victim and UPA was the perpetrator , so elitist intelletuals like you must have a ” POLITICAL MOTIVE ” in the Supreme Court’s unprecedented judgements. ( was fear of CONTEMPT OF COURT the reason behind you not writing a sensational editorial denouncing the Supreme Court ). EXECUTIVE HAS ALREADY LOST ITS CREDIBILTY BUT PUBLIC STILL HAS FAITH IN OUR JUDICIARY and ELECTION COMMISSION . So efforts to dismantle its essence will bear no fruits .
February 5th, 2009 at 1:48 pm
MODERATOR SIR ,
actually i have taken an extract form my respone to ” the hindu ” article … by mistake i forgot to correct the last paragraph .. plz correct it here ” you ” means N RAM , EDIT IN CHIEF , THE HINDU . “elitist intelletuals like you” etc.. plz delete this part .you can see MR N RAM editorial written in bad taste and as a lawyer of UPA here
http://www.hindu.com/2009/02/01/stories/2009020155090800.htm
February 5th, 2009 at 2:12 pm
CEC has just reasserted his grief over the lack of accord among the 3 member commission primarily due to Mr. Chawla’s partisan behavior and his vivid controversial personality from the times when he was not even in the commission. The fact that timings of CEC’s observations has not been appropriate should be conceived as a mere coincidence rather than denouncing it on grounds of ” vested interests ” or “being politically motivated ” as sadly “branded” by the elitist jurist and journalists.Encroachment of powers(alleged only , in this case ) may be alarming but its uncalled for nature should not shield cunning elements residing in constitutional bodies.The best remedy is not to appoint controversial figures to such crucial posts which act as a watchdog for a democracy . Also constitution is not clear about election commissioners( contrary to CEC Case ) removal as it is a new office . All we have is 1 - 2 “observations” of SC which can be moulded easily for serving one’s vested interests , as LAW MINISTERS and ELITIST media is doing .Credibility of Mr Gopalaswami cannot and should not be questioned on the grounds that he served under LK Adavani as his home secretary as TN Sheshan who served as Cabinet secretary under late Rajiv Gandhi is still remembered in India and abroad for his honesty and the “Electrol Reforms ” he gave to the largest democarcy . On the other hand Mr Chawla can not enjoy the same “credibility” as these two people as it “earned” not “granted”. Also reports that UPA is very reluctant and also childishly eager to go for elections under Mr Gopalaswami and Mr Chawla respectively compels to ponder over its hostility towards Mr Gopalaswami in particular and towards Election Commission as a whole . UPA and esp Congress has no moral right to question and verbally defame the CEC ( as law minister did ) ,as it is the sole culprit in setting an unwarranted trend by nominating former CEC MS Gill to Rajyasabha and then appointing him as a minister. This has opened a door for the ” political aspirations ” to election commissioners ,if they have any. One wonders whether Law minister was hinting towards Mr.Gill who has not ” spoiled ” his post retirement days .If NDA takes this matter to supreme court then Mr Chawla will not have to run for a Personal Lawyer as Law minister seems dying for that role . Efforts to tame Election commission by impulsive political helm will only kill the essence of our democracy in the long run and ” free and fair ” elections will become an Utopian dream.
February 5th, 2009 at 9:50 pm
We are very concerned with the news of the Times Now about ‘threat’ to Shri Advani in his website. ALL comments should be closely monitored and all sorts of technology should be used to TRACK THE IP ADDRESS to check who are visiting the website/blog and posting.
Law enforcement agencies must be intimated immediately.
Stay safe, India needs you at this critical juncture of its history.
February 6th, 2009 at 9:27 pm
Dear Mr Advani,
The Govt of Karnataka should take the Ram Sena issue very seriouslyl. It is really terrible if nothing is done about this. There is a big move from the Congress to attract the youth and with all the wrong doings of parties like the Ram Sena, the youth will move away from BJP ( just cause most people feel there is a link).
Today they are said to have targeted a CPM MLA’s daughter, and they are threatening to disrupt valentine Day celebrations…. Its only 3 months before the elections and please make sure the Karnataka Government maintains peace, law and order.
Regards
February 7th, 2009 at 10:21 am
I too agree with you. The role of Mr. Chawla is highly questionable. Any clean government should immediately replace him.
I love India but I feel very sad at the current state of affairs.
February 7th, 2009 at 12:44 pm
Dear Advaniji,
There is a space for every one to serve the country and undoubtedly the best place for a someone who knows “how the Congress works” is to be in the centre of affairs of that party itself. As an enthusiastic supporter of subversion of democracy during emergency years, there no better place for him than to take a role in leading Congress party and the country itself, if the party so decides.
Election Commission should remain above party politics. This has to be ensured by all the national parties, for their own good as well as for the wider interest of the democratic principles of the country. Any disruptive tactics played at this level will leave a greater damage to the body politic of the largest democracy in the world.
Chief Election Commissioner’s recommendation for removal of an Election Commissioner should not be derided as “suo motto”, but accepted as a binding recommendation as argued by Shri Arun Jaitley.
T. Harikrishnan
February 7th, 2009 at 5:34 pm
It is marvellous to see how the Gandhi family servants misconstrue almost everything that does not suit them. This party is clearly reverting to the tricks of Indira Gandhi’s times, day and age, who did anything to stay in power including destruction of the Indian bureaucracy, where she needed only YES MEN around her. Navin Chawla is a product of those times & continues as shameless bootlicker of the Gandhi family, who should never be given the position of CEC. The Shah commission had in its report said about Chawla, that the man is NOT FIT TO BE GIVEN ANY POSITION OF PUBLIC RESPONSIBILITY….. and an equally sycophantic present day Law Minister is busy breaking all laws and throwing the Constitution of India in the waste paper basket… all to please 10 Janpath. Now I am sure a Jayanti Natrajan or a Abhishek Singhvi will say that the Shah Commission was biased but the emergency was good. Every media channel and print media is busy criticising Mr Gopalswami without reading his report.
February 7th, 2009 at 5:35 pm
It is also very important that all CEC’s aqnd EC’s be banned from taking any Government appointments as Governors and even Ministers so that impartiality is maintained and they stay men of honour. However, Congress as a party is busy appointing only their henchmen not just EC’s but also give retired EC’s, who later became a CEC as Ministers in their council of Ministers. The present day UPA led Union Sports Minister - Mr Gill is a clear example of it, wonder what he did & how he pleased the first family of the Congress party when he was part of election commission.
February 7th, 2009 at 5:47 pm
The two guarantees for Indian democracy are for sure ― the Indian Army & the Election Commission’s independence and both of these we never treat well. We have downgraded our officers and men of the Armed Forces, while pampering the useless corrupt self serving men and women of Indian beauracracy and are now looking to destroy the Election Commission too by appointing bootlickers like Navin Chawla first as EC and now as a possibile CEC. What a disgrace.
February 7th, 2009 at 6:01 pm
AND most importantly the Speaker of Lok Sabha also joined the Press condemnation of CEC Gopalswami, of being critical of Mr Gopalswami of destroying the sanctity of the election commission…. wonder if Mr Speaker too went for a briefing to Congress/UPA headquaters before making press statement. Lok Sabha speaker should remember that the Election Commission is not a body under Indian Parliament. The CEC is a constitutional post by itself and CEC needs no ‘nasiyat’ from a lok sabha speaker who seems to be bought over by the UPA. CEC has a right to cleanup the election commission. Somnathda should have cleaned up the parliament of all the criminals in the parliament… but alas cud do nothing about the same.
February 8th, 2009 at 12:03 am
I have been a very consistent supporter of the BJP and Shri.Advani since over 2 1/2 decades.Shri.Vajpayee was a great PM for India.I keenly desire that the BJP comes back to power both at the centre as well as in M’tra & many other states.
However,even one or two odd cases of corruption by some BJP MLAs like in one recent case in K’taka,which I am visiting, boil my blood.
Corruption must be weeded out totally & rule of law must prevail regardless of political persons enjoying spoils of office.
Total ruthlessness in such matters is of paramount importance & urgency.Examples have to be set.
There is something to learn from waht president Obama said in his inaugural speech & I hope BJPN & it’s supremo too take few cues.As re:me,I shall & will be an ardent supporter of this party & wish it all the best.
February 8th, 2009 at 12:07 am
As re:Shri.Chawla,he must be eased out, if not thrown out as his continuance/elevation will cause irreparable damage in future!
May the voice of reason & justice prevail!
February 8th, 2009 at 2:52 am
Dear Sir,
With great respect for you and your party I would like to put forth my sentiments.
Being the true representative of the Indian Middle Class your party has done a lot of good things for this nation and the citizens. The, only issue that I am afraid of is about the liberty of a common citizen.
Being a citizen of the same ideology which you had cherished since last many years of your struggle against the pseudo secularism, I strongly believe that there are many issues that definitely disturbs a layman like me. The most recent being the Manglore issue where pub vendors were attacked by a mob of miscreants that called them the moral police for the religion and culture. I do agree that pub culture might not be liked by millions of Indians but it is a fact that even those attacked were Indian Citizens and they were not doing any harm to any other Citizens. …………..contd
February 8th, 2009 at 2:52 am
Dear Sir,
With great respect for you and your party I would like to put forth my sentiments.
Being the true representative of the Indian Middle Class your party has done a lot of good things for this nation and the citizens. The, only issue that I am afraid of is about the liberty of a common citizen.
Being a citizen of the same ideology which you had cherished since last many years of your struggle against the pseudo secularism, I strongly believe that there are many issues that definitely disturbs a layman like me. The most recent being the Manglore issue where pub vendors were attacked by a mob of miscreants that called them the moral police for the religion and culture. I do agree that pub culture might not be liked by millions of Indians but it is a fact that even those attacked were Indian Citizens and they were not doing any harm to any other Citizens.
……………contd
February 8th, 2009 at 2:53 am
Moreover, I am always surprised why Hindu culture or as such the Indian culture is believed to be so weak and helpless that few people drinking in bar can destroy it?? Since last thousands of years our culture has remained unbeaten and all the other cultures that touched us or reached us just vanished. So why, the issue of Indian culture being destroyed by few pub vendors and disco thecks is being raised uselessly. The worst part is that the party I support the most is supporting this issue.
Culture is made up of people. And let the people decide which culture they want to follow. Culture doesn’t make citizens, citizens do make the culture. IS this just a political gimmick? If yes then why at the cost of Indian Citizens?
February 8th, 2009 at 2:53 am
Further, on the election commission issue I do feel that what your party stands for is correct and justified. We the net - citizens of India are well aware of this fact but, in villages and cities where millions of Indian cast their votes keeping in mind the cast, creed and religion of the candidate, do you really think that putting your and your party’s energy in such non popular issue would do any help??
The present government has utterly failed in delivering its efforts. There are thousands of issues that can be raised. Anyhow, for the time being I wish you best of luck for the coming elections. I have myself started a blog http://www.metheindian.com and I am not sure whether you would be interested in putting your valuable posts on the same. If done so I would be greatly obliged and this I feel would support a great cause.
Warm regards,
live24×7
February 8th, 2009 at 11:09 am
i would like advani ji your blog represent true indian culture , atleast blog in different language including our natinal langauage hindi, so that it become true interative platform for all. hope your blog developer will take care of it
February 8th, 2009 at 11:34 am
Dear Sri. Advani ji and all friends,
Only in 1993 the Office of Chief Election Commissioner became a multi-member body ( from a single person office) with decision by majority. Though the Supreme Court had accepted the development, I personally feel that the AUTHORITY OF THE CHIEF ELECTION COMMISSION was effectively ERODED. It was like having 3 Prime Ministers or 3 Chief Justices or 3 Chief Ministers in place of ONE !!!!!
I am sure when Advani ji becomes the next Prime Minister of India, we will surely electoral reforms at the TOP first in office of the chief election commissioner itself.
It is a fact that the Present Election Commissioner has recommended BASED ON FACTS which are hard to ignore and he seem to have acted AS PER HIS CONSCIENCE which is good for India. The affected person has all the right to defend himself on impeachment proceedings which will have to hear him out before deciding. To say that the very recommendation is wrong is HEIGHT OF IDIOCY.
February 8th, 2009 at 10:25 pm
It is a matter of shame that one pillar of our democracy has been cracked by the COngress..One just shudders at the thought if thats the case with an EC, then how are the various officers faring across the country!!! IT s high time we realise how much pain and suffering the Congress has given to our country and how 10 years down the line we are headed for DISASTER
February 9th, 2009 at 7:52 am
I am afraid what CEC is doing is pathetic.
He seems to be acting partially leaning towards BJP because he was appointed by NDA ?
Then who is he to talk about impartiality?
What is the Red Line he draws on his forehead?
CEC should be above religious affiliations !
February 9th, 2009 at 2:20 pm
Ignore what prejudiced Winco walker says about CEC!
If the CEC sends a detailed recommendation to the President to dismiss the EC Shri.Chawla,she cannot be just sitting on it like she is sitting on the hanging of Afzal Guru case.
Most presidents are just rubber stamps of the ruling party/coalition & their big top on sitting in the chair are all hogwash.They only make hay while the sun shines!
The congress is the most thick-skinned,unscrupolous & unprincipled party being there only for the perpetual salvation of generations of only one family & is full of sycophants paying obesience to it’s deity & the prince!
Just look at the degradation of the Indian politics from the days of Shri.Seshan!
No wonder the supreme court made aremark last year that even God cannot save this country!
Throw out this uselsss,partisan EC Mr.Chawla without delay and also throw out this inept UPA govt without delay!
February 9th, 2009 at 10:37 pm
Shri Advaniji, Namaskar!
There are two very different aspects of CEC’s report. One is, as you’ve pointed out, it being binding on the govt. The second and the more important one is the matter contained in the report itself. In my opinion, these are two very different things and should be delinked from each other. I agree that the recommendations flow out of the report itself. That’s fine but for the sake of implementation they need to be delinked. I’ll further amplify on this.
Please consider, if you ask for an impartial inquiry on this issue (maybe by the Chief Justice) won’t the govt be compelled to do this? After all there have to be some very solid reason for the CEC to write a 90 page report in which he has cited 12 different instances where Mr Chawla’s actions have been inappropriate. Also, BJP may also ask for the report to be made public (there’s nothing secret in the report, I’m sure). Even if the govt doesn’t I’ll suggest the BJP ask for a copy under RTI or file a PIL.
February 9th, 2009 at 10:39 pm
Carrying on from part 1 of my reply.
Now, I admit that asking for an inquiry would be like accepting the fact that the recommendations of the CEC are not binding. I also admit that it would be a climb down from your party’s position. That, Sir, would be a small price to pay if the overall aim is kept sight of. Also, if I may, this should’ve been considered by the party before they made their stand public.
There’s another alternative for the party. File a case on these lines in the Supreme Court. Ask for both these things. Ask for removal of Mr Chawla and also for an inquiry into his conduct so that he can be punished as per the law. Let Supreme Court decide. In all probability it will order an inquiry which will eventually lead to the removal of Mr Chawla and resultantly, some kind of punishment as well.
Jai Hind!!
February 10th, 2009 at 9:25 am
Yea,remarkably successful democracy,thats why 40 people can molest 5 women in a pub,and walk away. Thats our culture, and thats what was being reinforced,no? Not a very big incident…ha,when will it be big? when your loved ones are the victims?
February 10th, 2009 at 10:12 am
Captsubash : Ignore me and you can ignore TRUTH and LOGIC as well !
February 10th, 2009 at 10:49 am
Dear Mr. Advani,
Now that you are thinking of becoming the PM of this great Nation [brought up with the sweat and hard work of sincere people like Mahatma Gandhi and Mother Teresa] , I have a few terse questions for you.
If once again you are faced with the Babri-Masjid Situation what will you do ? Will you flare up the hatred or bring PEACE to the troubled minds by your sagacious conduct and example !
Once again if Communal Riots break-out like in Gujarat [after the train accident] and your Typical BJP CM or Minister is just sitting on his chair and do nothing will you do something or nothing [as you did at that time] or act quick and strong [as duty bound-as per your oath] and bring the Rule of Constitution into force !!
If you can convince me that INDIA will not be doomed by you becoming PM but rather will prosper [not just only Hindus and Brahmins but all people created {equal} by Almighty God] I promise to vote for you !!!
February 10th, 2009 at 8:14 pm
I am not a veteran like you nor am I as old as you. I am only 51 yrs old & a Bengali. I am giving my ID only to help you understand what people of my age and a bengali may be thinking. I am sure you have started this BLOG TO Get that feedback? Or is it just a fad for you? You may not even be reading these messages and I bet someone paid by you is replying or noting these messages or MAYBE NOBODY is DOING THAT EVEN!
Without wasting your time, since I do not believe in you or in Mr Manmohan Singh or Mr Bajpayee, why am I not believing in anybody? Because even if I assume that as a person you are OKAY, you have to carry with yourself CROOKS!! And as long as as YOU carry crooks, YOU WILL NEVER BE BELIEVED!!!
Simple!
..CONTd to next msg
February 10th, 2009 at 8:15 pm
Now ask me what you can do? Nobody else comes forward, WHY NOT? Because to get VOTES or GET A TICKET one needs MONEY SAY I want to COME AND JOIN BJP.. Where do I have the money? So only crooks who have money come and join!! Can you change that?
LET ME come TO MY main point now.
I think your yedu- CM KARNATAKA- has lost it!
And you are going to suffer for that! Pakka!!
One one HAND SONIA from Italy is Promoting HIS DUMB SON who does not even know what is IAEA, and is back bencher in St Stephens to attract youngsters, who constitute a large number of voters on the other hand you have Yedu and HIS RAM SENA!!
AND THERE are you Not STOPPING THE dumb People who are linked to BJP to stop their STUPID activities. The thing that happened at Mangalore, is something that is going to Boomerang!,
CONTD to next
February 10th, 2009 at 8:16 pm
In any case I HAVE NOTHING FOR BJP, the ONLY Reason I will vote for BJP is because I hate CONGRESS and there IS nobody else AT the NATIONAL LEVEL, but then I too do NOT believe in you, because I AM A PSU worker, and a salaried middle class, and you ARE NOTHING BUT FOR THE BUSINESS CLASS, AS PROVED LAST TIME!
So this is my personal opinion, do you know what this means? I am sure you do!
NO SINGLE PARTY WILL GET ABSOLUTE MAJORITY and IT WILL ALWAYS BE A HUNG HOUSE AT THE CENTRE!
Question thus remains for my FELLOW COUNTRY MEN- HOW LONG WILL WE TOLERATE THESE CROOKS AND SELF SERVING INDIVIDUALS?
SAD
** end**
February 10th, 2009 at 8:22 pm
& yes.. Pls do visit http://wakeupoilsector.blogspot.com/ the blog of PSU officers and all salaried persons including DEFENCE !! AND NOTE HOW GOVTs have IGNORED THE SALARIED CLASS WHILE Promoting their Self interests.. Regards
February 11th, 2009 at 4:48 am
I believe the main issue with Pakistan is its Islamist make up. It is an indication of people’s inability to appreciate the views and beliefs of others, which is essential for democracy. This is also why vast majority of middle eastern countries are also quasi-democracy at best.
February 11th, 2009 at 9:38 am
Dear AdavaniJi,
While I do appreciate your concerns regarding the neutrality of the Election Commission and I do agree that it is of paramount importance, I have a few questions/suggestions:
1) Mr. Navin Chawla has been in the Election Commision since 2005. After that several elections have taken place in many of which BJP has won. Does not this imply that the Election Commision does not the power to manipulate the polls at all? Assuming Chawla is pro COngress and others neutral, the Congress should have successfully manipulated the Elections?
2) I personally believe that the BJP instead of gunning for Chawla should have demanded the resignation of both CHawla and Gopalaswamy for the sake of the Commission. It would have shielded the BJP from Congress counter offensive and might have brought this crises to a meaningful resoultion.
3) If the BJP does come to power, will your Govt. implement reforms in the commsion?
Hoping for a reply of some sorts.
With Regrds,
Gaurav Garg
February 11th, 2009 at 9:46 am
MR.WINCO WALKER
WHAT DO YOU THINK OF INDIA.IS IT A BANANA REPUBLIC.IS IT A TERRORIST SATTE.IF BJP WOULD HAVE WANTED IT WOULD HAVE CONSTRUCTED THE RAM TEMPLE IN 1992 BUT TILL 2009 IT IS NOT CONSTRUCTED.SO MR WALKER THINK THAT INDIANS ARE PASSIONATE,LOVELY AND PEACEFUL.THEY NEVER HAVE ANY COMPLEX HIGH OR LOW.THEY DO THINK ALL AS INDIAN, ALBEIT OTHERS MAY NOT HAVE THOUGHT SO.WE INDIAN ARE NEVER SUPPORTIVE OF ANY RIOT AND VIOLENCE AS TAUGHT BY MAHATMA GANDHI BUT SOME PEOPLE DO HAVE A TENDENCY TO DERIVE PLEASURE BY INCITING THE INDIANS.SOME PEOPLE HAVE GETTING SADISTIC PLEASURES FROM DECRYING LEADERS LIKE LKADVANI.YOU MAY NOT VOTE FOR HIM BUT THE FACT IS THAT HE IS A NATIONALIST,PATRIOTIC,SECULAR AND MOST IMPORTANTLY INDIAN.WHO THINK HIMSELF AS INDIAN NEVER THOUGHT AS YOUR MINDSET.
February 11th, 2009 at 9:56 am
if at all india is to prosper it is high time that we all indian should go for construction of the ram temple in ayodhya in a place other than the disputed site and leave the disputed site so that the so called liberals and secularists would get to know the truth of the whole matter and stop blaming bjp.what is wrong in construction of the temple in ayodhya.the disputed land or site be converted to an grand park with flowers of peace.we shouldnot delayed the matter any more .this step would clsoe the dirty mouths of communalists.(I do approve that the pseudo secularists should be termed as communalists)
February 11th, 2009 at 2:13 pm
Sainthood to sonia
“Vatican has recognaized Sonias contribution towards spreading Christa_nity in India. There are estimated one lakh Missio_neries in India who have successfully converted more than 5 million Hindus & Muslims to Christanity in past five years. She has appointed five chri_stain chief ministers in Congress ruling states including AP.Even a poor performer like A K Antony has become a Defence misister because of his religion.Ambika Soni, Oscar Fernandis played key role in UPA govt because of their Chri_stain status. The person (Alphonsa) who died 60 years back has got Saint hood from Vatican because of Sonias recomandation to please Kerala Voters. Wake up citizens , this is the high time to revolt against UPA…Jai Hind”
Advanji Highlite this sentence in media sure it will help u a lot.
My suggestion : Poach some congress mid ring MP…..ask him to say these comments in media….
Advanji we need you to save our country…..
February 11th, 2009 at 2:53 pm
Well, India is democratic nation and become success bcoz of independent armed forces and Election Commission as stated by advani ji. It’s natural true that these both body of the country should be neutral. For them each and every person is equal. they should behave biass free.
February 11th, 2009 at 3:51 pm
Winco I would seriously recommenf you to read My Country my life and that will answers a lot of your questions, I mean there has to be a reason why the country is so raped for the last 50 something years that the Congress has ruled and why even within 5 years there was a more methodical development, a lot of processes and constitutional posts were given due respects….I mean first the Supreme Court, not CEC, the Congress is coming on the wrong side of everything….
Secondly to you point about Gujrat, mind you post Godhra there has been nothing, state has developed and is a model state that can put other CM’s to shame as to where there is a will for development there are no boundaries…..Once the politics of communal appeasement is stopped will India develop whole heartedly….NO ANTI NATIONAL ELEMENTS SHOULD BE ENCOURAGED…SPECIALLY ON THE PLANKS OF VOTE BANK POLITICS!!!
February 11th, 2009 at 8:18 pm
Sub: Is India another Somalia?
Dear Sir,
The Asian Human Rights Commission (AHRC) has received information regarding the case of four-year-old boy, Khusbuddin, who died of acute malnutrition in Harpalpur village of Kashi Vidyapith Block, Varanasi district in Uttar Pradesh state. The AHRC has been informed by the People’s Vigilance Committee on Human Rights (PVCHR), a local human rights organisation working in Uttar Pradesh state that Khusbuddin was suffering from Grade IV malnutrition which resulted in his death. Seceral children die because of Govt negligence to the serious issues.
What’s your plan to make india free of malnutrition?
Narcissus321 from IIT India.
February 12th, 2009 at 9:20 pm
Dear Advani ji,
I just finished reading your autobiography last week. Please accept my humble and thankful pranams to you for your lifetime of service to the nation.
I have a suggestion. The current CEC, Mr.N.Gopalaswami’s tenure must be extended by two months so he can supervise the upcoming Parliamentary elections in April/May. Only Mr.N.Gopalaswami’s presence as CEC can ensure a free and impartial parliamentary election process.
February 13th, 2009 at 7:41 am
Namaskaram Advaniji,
A person who has the potential to reach the highest office in India should be unbiased. Don’t you feel the spat between these two people is an excellent example of clash of egos? This is how you judge people? The constitutional article should not be misconstrued or misunderstood. By the way, any government office should not lean towards any party. Why are forward caste people supporting BJP? They think the party belongs to them. But why people from SC community are denied even basic posts and why they feel they are not part of the party. Think advaniji and try the right things, who knows you may even end up as PM. But, i would not vote for you in my life or in death for one simple reason, you will never help us remove this caste nonsense from our minds as well as from our educational institutions. Because This is where you can sensationalize politics.
February 13th, 2009 at 11:04 am
OFFENSIVE IS THE BEST DEFENSE.who has said this is actually true.we need to go fully offensive on the betrayers,oppositions of bjp.pseudo-secularists,communalists,communists,corrupts,
terrorists and anti bjp media are the enemies of indian democracy.the way they are ruining the country it is shameful for them.we read your speech in ficci yesterday and get to know the latest position of indian economy and your future projections.we are highly charmed by your future planning.we have high hopes on the ability of bjp to streamline the indian economy which is needed to be made self sufficient,self relient,swadeshi.if we transform the total planning on rural based then the country would progress like any thing and the people would return back to villages from towns.if the indian model of progressive economy be introduced in india then the world would also emulate it.it is the indian model which would work in india,where 80% people live in rural areas with rural based economy.
February 14th, 2009 at 1:24 am
GOOD NEWS FOR BJP-i gt my voters ID card…now 1 more vote to bjp..:-)
I have some important things for the BJP regarding the next elections.
I am a serious hindu and have discovered few wonderful methods of gaining Congress Vote-bank.
Seriously, this method can give you 100 votes/30 minutes effort. ask ny bjp official to Reach me at prat_id69@yahoo.com and i will share it with them(without any fee).I have also collected various mis-deeds of congress government, the good things of congress which were actually bad for the citizens in the long run, with proofs…mail me and take them from me. i dont want to paste them here otherwise any congress would use the same methodology…Trsut me this method would make you win..(pls ask d bjp official to identify himself when he mails me, i dont want congressis to fool me)..
February 14th, 2009 at 2:46 am
Dearest sir,
In my opinion,Naveen chavla should should go.There is enough evidence since 1970,that chavla is honest to gandhi family. He did lot of favour to Indira gandhi and sanjay gandhi.He also receaved upliftment during Rajiv gandhi. finally ,as a whole he is obedient to congress. Its very unfortunate that he elevated to level of election commosioner. what ever constitution says,what ever may be the Gopalswamys letter ,he should be removed by majority voting in parliment.
February 14th, 2009 at 8:50 am
Dear Sir,
It would be great if you can join following two professional / social networking forums. It will give opportunity to Indian professionals working here & overseas to discuss various issues with you.
1. LinkedIn- http://www.linkedin.com
2.Facebook- http://www.facebook.com
Regards,
Srini
February 15th, 2009 at 12:27 pm
Respected Advani Ji,
The EC must be a neutral body, not filled by partisans. EC Chawla did not reply to the letter of CEC for six months and when he got the reply and did not find it suitable, he sent his letter to the President. This aspect is being ignored by a section of press and motive is being discovered behind CEC’s letter.
The open comment by Law minister in favour of Navin Chawla shows the partisanship and malafide intention of the incumbent Government for the forthcoming LS polls.
Since acts of Navin Chawla are not independent and free from Political Bias his impartiality cannot be relied upon. Mr. Navin Chawla is acting at the behest of his favorite political party and it would be more dangerous to allow such a person to lead such a highest constitutional authority of India. Hence CEC’s move to oust Chawla is right.
February 15th, 2009 at 12:31 pm
…contd frm previous
The President should take his own independent decision in this regard. The best choice of CEC should be in consultation with Leader of Opposition and speaker, this way the choice of EC members would become truly impartial.
February 15th, 2009 at 10:05 pm
Winco Walker has fallen short of attributing development of India to Sonia Gandhi. Poor chap? Take pity on him and just ignore him.
February 17th, 2009 at 9:08 am
Hi
It was so saddening to read the news of molestation and alleged rape of a foreigner at the time when our moral police was busy fighting helpless couples on Valentines Day….a small request to our Goonds brothers….pls protect women from getting raped, molested and eve teased if they really feel they want to defend Indian culture….Our Indian culture is very tolerant and worships females….there are enough rapists,molesters,eve teasers,perverts,despos roaming in the country who need to be dealt with rather than burn pink chaddis on streets…..this will be a positive way of atleast winning the trust of the young Indians…..We Indians are a very happy lot and do not leave any opportunity to be happy…while I am against obscenity on valentines day I oppose any effort to cull the freedom of the people ala Taliban…..the dangers of Talibanisation are real but Taliban altest protects the females from anti social elements….here we have a moral police who is perhaps moraless!!!
February 18th, 2009 at 3:25 am
Dear Advaniji,
You are talking about words by “BUTTO”, our dear and loving neighboring country FAILED LEADER. who knows only to pain India & Indians.
I hate to see you taking a testimony from them. I am really pissed off when i see you posted a blog after seeing 26/11.
February 18th, 2009 at 10:19 am
IAS officers work with politicians throughout their career and after their reitrement when appointed as CEC one should not expect they are insulated from political influence. To achieve personal goal, they all seek patronage of political parties.
Any further debate on CEC has no substance but eyewash.
February 19th, 2009 at 12:05 am
Dear advaniji,
i dont agree with your view that the CEC recomendations are binding on the president.while making constitution ,constitution makers clearly needed to create a election comission independent from the Excutive. to protect the independence of the election comission the CEC has been made to removed on the same ground as that of judge of supreme court. but they wanted to protect other election comissioners from Executive through the office of CEC. this is why CEC recomendations were made binding on the president.this should be read when the recomendations of council of minister are different from that of CEC ,the president should accept the CEC recomendation.itmeans the CEC recomendation are binding only when president make reference to CEC this is to say CEC dosnot enjoy suo motto powers to intiate the removal process of other election comissioner.
February 19th, 2009 at 12:04 pm
That is what is expected from the ruling party - BULL run whatever suits the party. Traditionally this CNGRESS has done everything possible to meet its needs be it executive, judiciary etc etc. STRONG PUBLIC OPINION in favour of merit is the need of the hour.
February 19th, 2009 at 5:23 pm
The matter regarding Navin Chawla and Election commission has actually been misquoted and deliberately presented in diffrent context by a section of polity and media of our nation. Actually they have two important points in this regard: 1. time of recommendation by the CEC & 2. suo-moto power of the CEC Let us examine both these issues from the constitution of India and article 324(5); wherein interpretation is I think in favour of present reccommendatin of the CEC.Regarding time of recommendation, the opposition is actually to divert the mind of people making noise..We must think that what should be our main emphasis in this regard…you have rightly written in yr blog that Election Commission has been one of the strongest pillers of our democracy. Insertion of such a maligned persion as EC and his dark records (As per Shah Commission on Emergency) should have been main point of discussion.Any way, ours is a vibrant and strongest democracy and our people r mature to understand reality
February 20th, 2009 at 5:41 pm
To all loud mouths finding fault with CEC,
The CEC Mr. Gopalaswami is a man of highest integrity and to many idiots this would appear rather strange.
What these loud- mouths and no-brainers have failed to see is that the The CEC Mr. Gopalaswami has also said that THERE SHOULD BE A BAR ON ELECTION COMMISSIONERS occupying SOME OTHER OFFICE after EXITING ELECTION COMMISSION!!!!!
Usually we find all Officers mouthing INTEGRITY ONLY AFTER RETIREMENT !!!! But Mr. Gopalaswami has said that while he is still in service.
To me just for this ACT OF HONESTY AND INTEGRITY, Mr. Gopalasami deserves BHARAT RATNA…
I just want to ask this question? Supposing there is truth behind what Mr. Gopalasami has said about Mr. Navin Chawla, then what he is supposed to do? Put up all the files and make a nice pillow and sleep on it?
February 21st, 2009 at 5:16 pm
While I agree that Chawla Should go, I have few coments. How can a former Lok Ayukta was allowed to join BJP in Karnataka? Former Election Commissioners, Lok Aykta’s and Judges of all Courts should not join any political party and Political parties should not admit them.
Tax Payers money should not be spent on Temples, muts, maszids, Churches and relegious rituals. When the country is lacking in Health ad education facilities and infrastructure facilities like proper roads How can we spend tax payers money on building temples and celeberating birthdays of swamijees. Ministers should not attend such functions and waste public fund. One such birthday of a well respected swamijee was attended by 4 lakh people forget about Govt spending. even if each person spends Rs 1000 on anaverage just for travel related expenses it is Rs. 40 Crores Why sanyasis should celeberate their or allow others celeberate their B’days? and waste money like this?
February 22nd, 2009 at 5:17 am
SUN 47 MEIN BHARAT CONG DUARA AAZAAD HUAA.AAJ HUM SUB KO MIL KAR BHARAT KO CONG SE AAZAAD KARVAANA HAI.SIYAASAT KE NAAM PAR SHOSHAN KARNEY WAALI UN SABHI PARTIYON SE AAZAAD KARVAANA HAI JO ,ANDAR HI ANDAR DEEMAK KI TARAH HUMAARI MAATR BHOOMI KO KHOKHLAA KARTI CHALI JAA RAHI HAIN.
RESPECTED SRI ADVANIJI ,WE HAVE TO WIN THIS ELECTION TO SAVE OUR NATION ,SIR THE COUNTDOWN HAS BEGUN AND I CONGRATULATE YOU IN ADVANCE CAUSE I KNOW FOR A FACT THAT U AND ONLY YOU SHALL BECOME THE PM .INSHALLAAH AMEEN .THE BJP SHALL WIN BY A HUGE MAJORITY ,INSHALLAAAH AMEEN .
JAI HIND
THANKING YOU
YOUR SON IN PATRIOTISM,FAITH AND VISION
FAIZAAN KHAN
(SIR KINDLY CHECK YOU (SANSAD.NIC)MAILBOX I HAVE SENT A GIFT FOR YOU SIR .JAI HIND
February 22nd, 2009 at 12:08 pm
After 1984, the pseudo-secular regime of Nehruvians forced NO-ENTRY situation for Sikhs in the Armed forces.Administrative as well as Judiciary failed to give justice to 1984 Sikh- massacre victim famillies. Nehruvians and left combine created tthe monster of naxalites, that played hovoc with the lives of poor Indians for decades. Emergency is one of major heinious crimes of CONGRESS……………. Sentence of SUKHRAM, former cabinet minister of Narsimha Rao Government, is the proof of decaying of our system. CBI has become a political tool of the ruling party.
Mr. Gopalaswami,s letter to President is mirror that shows the whole scenario.
February 22nd, 2009 at 3:21 pm
Dear Mr.Advani
This comment is not related to this post. Nonetheless, it is of extraordinary importance and urgency, hence I have posted it here.
While you are engaged on topics, obviously of national importance, I would bring to your attention the danger that is developing on our western border. Barbaric forces are gaining ascent in our neighbouring country at a frightening pace. It is a matter of time before Pakistan becomes what Afganistan was before 2002. This poses an extremely grave risk to to the free, peaceful and democratic society that we have built since Independence.
I request you Dear Sir, as the leader of the largest opposition party to lead a crusade for a national consensus cutting across party lines to recognise this as a serious national danger and indeed a danger to civilisation, and to initiate steps within our country and outside along with countries uphold and cherish values of democracy and peace, to exterminate this evil for good.
Regards
Rabindranath
February 22nd, 2009 at 4:19 pm
Dear Mr. Advani,
India has awaken and can not sleep. Mr. Naveen Chawla has to go. Who will try to keep him will pay. Indian Citizens will take him to task.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UChUu4QZgxU
February 22nd, 2009 at 8:44 pm
Sir, A simple question why BJP not come forward strongly ( by hook or crook methods) on these points (a long list) which make waves in different classes. BJP have many leaders to fight on these points according to their quality.
February 22nd, 2009 at 9:13 pm
Advani ji,
Sat Shree Akal,
ANT-ODAYA is a great idea of Pt. Deen Dayal Upadhayaye ji. Can it become your next topic?
Poor masses of India is expecting a lot from you.
February 23rd, 2009 at 10:34 am
Advani ji
Every party uses bureaucrats after retirement including bjp. Then why are you worried about chawla. People are not fools they understand every thing you politician say. at least those using internet…………Sir think about new india stronger india young india ……MAY GOD GRANT YOU THE STRENGTH TO BECOME PM ONE DAY
February 24th, 2009 at 9:30 pm
Dear Advaniji
This is my first posting
Include “corruption free India’ in your goals or agendas in the front page with other goals
February 26th, 2009 at 9:14 am
I used to be a strong supporter of BJP in my college days and was a active worker for ABVP in JNU and Delhi University. But now i think BJP is no more concerned about the development of the country. They always have a issue of RAM Mandir..Just wanted to tell you Mr. Advani that Ram Mandir will not feed a hungry man in india. Ram Mandir will not give employment to a youth of India.
Now every youth of India wants employment and development of the country. And I think congress is doing very well in the areas of development. We all can see the changed look of Delhi…
Thanks
vinod
February 27th, 2009 at 1:41 pm
sir,
T.
I have a straight question of you ( i hope u will reply straight).
mr. chand mohd former dy cm of haryana was absconding for nearly 45 days why he was paid salary. in gujarat your party minister dr. mayaben kodani was absconding for a week before getting anticipatory bail.i am not here to go after individuals but tell me how u will check these thing systematically . if not next time probably prime minister will be absconding for some days …that may create problems
regards
priyank
February 27th, 2009 at 1:58 pm
Dear sir,
thoretically u r right.
in reality all the post are political apppointees only
typical examples are governors of states, DGPs, chief sec Ec,
prob is not about a or two people . problem is about admistrative reforms
police reforms were not done by government even by yours . despite of supreme court
repeated observation. political bias problrm will be there if u politicians every thing as per ur choice. be a sports man don,t cry foul u guys have done same in appointments
regards
February 28th, 2009 at 12:46 pm
HI Advaniji,
you are absolutely right about CEC.irrespective of navin chawla or anybody, one should make sure that all constitutional positions should be given to non controversial and politically neutral persons then only the public faith in the institution of democracy will remain intact.
The UPA govt. under congress has always tried to undermine such posts for petty gains.
i remember that one major task they done is to remove all governors appointed by NDA in bulk.
Removing National womens commission member nirmala is the latest instance.
.
February 28th, 2009 at 12:47 pm
HI Advaniji,
One of the major criticism about you is about your age.
Nobody can help that,again i dont think it is a disadvantage,morarji bhai too was above 80.
after all any one who has good health ,sound memory power is qualified,as pm”s or any minister’s post dont require tasks to be done physically.
The more experienced a person is,he will be able to manage a coalition,deal with pressure situations.and guide the nation to prosperity like a head of undivided hindu family.
it is not mandatory to be a young person to understand the feelings and tastes of young people.
we dont have to look at the west and compare the age of heads of other nations.
March 4th, 2009 at 10:30 pm
I’m very sad that Mr Chawla has been appointed as CEC effective April. Had it been Mr Abdul Kalam as President, he would have had a re-look at the Government’s recommendation about this appointment.
Also I was sad to read report in TOI about MPs’ attendance, participation in Question & Answer session in Parliament. Also very few BJP MPs figure in best 5 list. Hope this will improve in next session. Hope you will have a guideline given to your MPs on this.
March 8th, 2009 at 9:39 pm
Dear Advani ji, You are talking logical but then who is there to listen especially among people who are decision makers in governance. We have to find solutions for such undemocratic steps.
Congress has been doing these for last six decades. We in 21st century are fortunate to see these undemocratic decisions because of some transparancies. However these remain a challenge to do right things. Even President was chosen without much support or approval from large section of population.
Indians are poor and they do not have time and enmergy to think in this direction. You are a hope. We look toawrds you to show us the path. God bless you and you lead us. We are with you.
kamekish
March 9th, 2009 at 12:31 am
Advaniji,
Every Indian who thinks rationally and a Loktantrik by nature is convinced that conduct of Naveen Chawla is biased and hence officers like him do not deserve such highly responsible posts. Response of government and Congress was not surprising and can be very much anticipated. But what surprised me the response of our Media. Media acted actually in favour of Mr. Chawla by not questioning and high-lighting his biased act but indirectly supported Congress and Chawla by attacking current CEC and also putting BJP actions in questions.
Does all this concerns you and force to think you that our country needs an un-biased media who does not act on some ones behalf or does not oppose one party’s ideology (who is representative of millions of Indians). This later charge also says that our media has its own political ideology which I believe is not good for our democracy.
Also I feel if you have got such hostile media, BJP needs a media policy, plans and really excellent speakers.
March 31st, 2009 at 5:17 pm
Dear Sir,
When other party specially Congress criticize NDA govt. on Kandahar episode, why don’t you give them a befitting reply. Your govt should not have released terrorist because only ordinary Indians were hostage, not high profile politician like Mehbooba Mufti. Your govt released terrorist to save so many Indians unlike Congress that release so many terrorist for Mehboobs Mufti Sayed…
And at Kandahar time time all the family members were begging for their loved one’s life…. through live TV channels… and So called Secular tv channels were also showing emotional story.
Sir you must stand by and defend NDA Govt. decision and never forget to mention Mehbooba Mufti episode.
April 5th, 2009 at 7:54 pm
Advaniji,Sadar Pranam!
People have lost faith in the media. MOST OF OUR MEDIA IS OWNED & CONTROLLED BY FOREIGNERS.Hindus won’t tolerate false allegations on Hindu Saints.
in order to divert the attention of the society from JIHADI TERRORISM, Mrs. Sonia Gandhi has started a campaign to implicate Hindu Saints and organisations in different cases and humiliate then, although they have even remotely no connection with such activities.
they are in the fear of losing the forthcoming Parliament Elections.
But we wish to tell Sonia that her policy to humiliate the Hindu saints will ultimately result in country wide massive agitation which will dog her steps until the elections.
We can’t forget the humiliation of the Kanchi Sankaracharga, Sri Asha Ram Babu ji, and other saints of kerala and recently the gruesome murder of Swami Lakshmanananda which was sponsored by the church.
The country belongs to the saints and not to Sonia Ganghi. This message will go round every village.
April 7th, 2009 at 9:55 am
Dear Sir,
Don’t you think there should be enough power to Income Tax Dept. So that corrupt politicians don’t fill there account.
Mayawati is highest tax payer. Don’t you think she got too much of gifts. There should be strong rules for gifting. There should be some upper limit for the amount of gift. (not in Millions and Billions of Rupee).
Current law helped them to make the black money into white money. If this law wasn’t there then the amount would have gone to swiss bank.
How a politician can earn property in crores in 1 tenure of 5 years ? Are the laws of India are so week to catch these corrupt politicians ?
How do you plan to stop this corruption ?
India has seen enough of corruption now India needs reform in all forms!
Unhappy Citizen of India
April 15th, 2009 at 11:46 am
respected sir,
i love my bjp party so much as i love my india. but what was going in karnataka under your leadership is not so good. CM of karnataka not concentrating on goverment but on concentrating on oppsite patty members an brigning in bjp. so it is a good for future of bjp development. so it is not wellfare to give ticket of M.P to C.M SOn.
Sir today congress party putting issue of plane highjack during nda goverment when bjp trying putting issue of terrisom in front of people. so why not bjp speakers try to convience people that what indhra gandhi did and what rahjiv gandhi did during their goverment.
kashmir issue is ended at indra gandhi at the time of simla karar so she done nothing than hering of ameica . rajiv gandhi won by 400 seats after indraji death so what he did nothing chane constitution. our first prime minister alwys want to get shanti nobel if if sardar patel isnot taht time india may be in difficult at that time.